Call us 24/7 877-670-2421

Tobacco Companies Win in FDA Fight – Federal Judge Grants Injunction Against FDA Required Graphic Warnings on Packaging

The tobacco companies are celebrating a victory over the federal government today, because Federal District Judge Richard Leon just granted their request for an injunction – an order that blocks the Food & Drug Administration’s requirement that tobacco products start being sold with really, really graphic warnings on them about the dangers of humans using tobacco products.  (For details, see our earlier posts here and here.)

You can read the November 7, 2011, Order granting the injunction here.

However, it’s not over till it’s over.

The Order only stays things for a certain period of time.  Fifteen (15) months, to be exact.  This, according to the judge’s ruling, should be enough time for the merits of the controversy to be decided.

Problem is, Judge Leon’s decision already hints as to how that’s going to play out: in his accompanying opinion, he’s ruled that it’s more likely than not that the cigarette manufacturer plaintiffs are going to win on their Constitutional claims against the federal government, i.e., that the proposed regulations violate free speech protections provided in the U.S. Constitution.

Leon is suggesting that the FDA’s regulation goes past an approved notice on the facts of smoking and into a value judgment on the use of tobacco.  If the FDA regulation is found to include a value judgment, then it is entering an area of advocacy on the issue, and that’s not allowed under the Constitution.

Lots of folks are very upset about this decision.

Tobacco use kills people – doesn’t seem much point in arguing that as anything but fact these days, right?  To get a gist of the growing public response, read the news release for TobaccoFreeKids which hit the news wire today.

Contact Us

If you or a loved one has been seriously injured or killed due to the wrongful acts of another, then you may have a legal claim for damages as well as the right to justice against the wrongdoer and you are welcomed to contact the Northwest Indiana and Chicagoland personal injury lawyers at Allen Law Group to schedule a free initial legal consultation.

    Our
    Locations

    Nearest Office View All Locations
    Allen Law Building
    501 Allen Court, Chesterton, IN
    (219) 465-6292
    Capital Center
    201 N. Illinois Street, Indianapolis, IN
    (317) 842-6926
    Chicago Loop Office
    77 W. Wacker Dr. Suite 4500
    (312) 236-6292
    Justice Center
    3700 E. Lincoln Highway, Merrillville, IN
    (219) 736-6292
    Regency Office Suites
    10062 W. 190th Place, Mokena, IL
    (815) 725-6292
    Orland Park Executive Tower
    15255 S. 94th Avenue, Orland Park, IL
    (708) 460-6292

    New Coffee Creek Location

    501 Allen Court, Chesterton IN 46304

    Render of new Ken Allen Law Group location in Coffee Creek
    Render of new Ken Allen Law Group location in Coffee Creek